Foundation of Teaching and Learning - THLE 701 - Section 421
See assignment below:
Memorable Lesson
During the first week of the Design Thesis Workshop, a module called "Different Directions" was taught asynchronously. The learning outcomes for this module were for the students to prepare their thesis for feedback and complete Milestone 1, due at the beginning of the following week. In this lesson, students defined their thesis statements and selected a multidisciplinary project to solve a problem using design solutions. For example, they could create a fictitious organization to educate people about the effects of homelessness. Additionally, they developed a logo for their organization. The lesson incorporated some principles of Universal Design for Learning (UDL).
Engagement
The UDL engagement principle is shown through an outline of the first assignment’s objectives, including specific details of what to include within the assignment and how to submit the assignment, which was in written format only. The outline allowed students to know what was expected of them to work towards the goal of their final assignment.
Representation
Most of the lesson used written material with visual examples of the content, including final thesis booklets from previous students, a recorded slide presentation, closed captions, visual examples, and a supplied slide deck to aid in explaining the lesson's content. Extra formats, such as YouTube videos with captions, were added to the module's material.
Action & Expression
An in-depth explanation, in list form, was included at the beginning of the lesson to show the main focus points, including what was due the following week. A discussion board was also available for the students to submit their work in progress for peer review and feedback.
After the lesson, the students still had quite a few questions. They required additional clarification of expectations, including the length of their thesis statement and the requirements of the logo submission. The students did not feel confident with the following steps. Even though their submissions were primarily successful at fulfilling the assignment requirements, substantial feedback is needed to guide them in the right direction to be successful in the next milestone. Therefore, additional revisions to this lesson will help create a more accessible, asynchronous and inclusive learning environment.
Reimagined Lesson Using UDL
Further implementation of UDL principles should be included to ensure the students feel confident in building a solid foundation for their thesis project.
Engagement
To allow students to be fully engaged within the course, feel confident and have more control of their learning environment, the following will be added to the module:
- Assignment Outlines & Rubrics - A critical first step to creating a UDL-centred asynchronous environment by creating in-depth assignment outlines allows students to manage their time effectively, solidify their course expectations, and maintain personal goals. Within these assignment outlines, rubrics will be created and made visible to the students ahead of time, providing various levels and explaining each level's objectives and what will be graded to achieve each level. Some rubrics are currently part of the course. However, they do not include a level system.
- Discussion Boards - Adding a discussion board to the course to allow students to share their work in progress throughout the course for peer feedback will help create community and provide additional support as they work through their assignments. This would be implemented using the discussion board feature within eCentennial.
- Mentimeter Online Trivia/H5P Activities - Trivia questions about the design elements and principles used within the milestone could be added to recall their previous knowledge. One way to implement this would be to use the quiz feature in Mentimeter, embedding it within the lesson or using it within the weekly drop-in session with attendees. Having recently done this with students, they enjoyed the interactive components of Mentimeter, as well as its slight competitiveness when using the leaderboards, turning it more into a game.
Another way would be to embed H5P activities within the module, creating an activity to match the element/principle with their definition.
Representation
To allow students to have multiple sources of representation of the information.
- Graphic Organizer - Create a digital, fillable PDF graphic organizer to outline the specific elements required within the thesis statement, including defining their target audience and the problem and solution with thought-prompting questions. Creating this in a digital format with visuals would allow students to use it on their computers, using communication aids, if necessary. This large task is made more accessible by using a target audience-defining workbook for small-business owners, the Dream Client Workbook, made for Broadbent Studio as a base and adapting the information to fit the students’ needs.
- Accessible Audio and Video Formats - The lesson material is mainly supplied using written material with a few visual examples, further improving the content by sourcing more videos with closed captions and audio resources to explain how to execute the learning objectives. Implementing more audio examples, for example, from Podcaster such as DGDC - Deeply Graphic Designcast and their episode Building the Perfect Creative Brief (DGDC - Deeply Graphic Designcast, 2022), would greatly benefit the lesson as there currently are none.
Action & Expression
To allow students to showcase their knowledge flexibly.
- Additional Submission Formats - Giving students more format options to submit their thesis statements to comply with the Universal Design for Learning (UDL) principle would be helpful. Additionally, it would be beneficial to extend these options to include the submission of the final thesis booklet in various formats. The thesis statement and the final thesis booklet submissions require a written PDF format. However, making these changes could involve a significant effort. Allowing students to express themselves in their preferred format is essential. Since assignments represent various milestones accomplished during the course, enabling students to submit their assignments in the form of videos would still meet the course's objectives of "present and defend a multi-disciplinary design solution" (Lea et al., 2024), as well as essential employability skills, such as "communicate clearly, concisely and correctly in written, spoken, and visual form that fulfills the purpose and meets the needs of the audience" (Lea et al., 2024).
- Brainstorming and Discussion with Peers - Easily adding a discussion board within eCentennial creates an extra ungraded discussion board for students to share their unfinished work and ideas with their classmates. Helping create a sense of community and provide continuous feedback, often unavailable through the instructor alone. It also gives students the chance to collaborate.
- Assignment Outlines - Additionally, categorizing the assignment outlines previously suggested in the ‘Engagement’ sections into this principle by aiding the students with a checklist of assignment requirements and allowing them to pace themselves actively.
Importance and Benefits of Incorporation of UDL
Implementing UDL is crucial for this lesson and course so that students can learn more independently through an asynchronous online platform without as much assistance from the instructor. As the lesson is currently designed, it is tough to teach within an asynchronous setting, as it relies heavily on the instructor to explain the lesson’s concepts further as they are not as clearly defined. Also, due to the intensely tight timelines of this 6-week course, late submissions cannot be tolerated to meet all the course requirements within this short timeline, and extensive external factors can quickly add up to decrease the learners’ success.
All learners have many external stressors, including but not limited to juggling multiple jobs or work on the side, are parents, and have many personal worries and obligations within their family life that distract them from their full-time studies. These are some of the main issues that impede their time for studies, making them feel more stressed and overwhelmed. These feelings inhibit their cognitive load, making it challenging for them to comprehend unclear instructions and concepts. Therefore, creating a learning environment that is accessible and straightforward and reduces their cognitive load is imperative for their educational success.
The UDL approach prioritizes all learners' needs and can be further developed through the examples below.
Engagement
Adding detailed assignment pages and rubrics within each module addresses the issue of engagement in a course. Rubrics and assignment pages help students manage their time effectively by clearly outlining their expectations, creating achievable goals, and creating ways to access their learning throughout the module. It will also enable them to focus more effectively on meeting the course outcomes. This approach will benefit students with disabilities, including those with cognitive disabilities, by providing explicit instruction to reduce confusion.
Representation
Additionally, studies show that online reading has evolved to quickly allow a glance of information. Therefore, using sub-headings and bullet points to write assignment requirements provides clear instructions, making it easier for students with communication difficulties to comprehend the written instructions. This approach will also benefit other students in the class.
It is also necessary to provide more accessible information formats within the course. For example, adding podcasts will help learners with visual impairments access the information without using a screen reader to read the lecture pages. Alternative formats will also allow learners who are commuting and have less time to access the information in a hands-free format. Adding more video content with closed captions will allow students with auditory, cognitive, and communication disabilities to access the information in a visual, easy-to-digest way that is not as overwhelming as reading the lecture notes or using a screen reader.
Lastly, creating a graphic organizer for crafting the thesis statement will be helpful for learners with cognitive and communication disabilities. Graphic organizers provide a visual guide to help them through the writing process.
Action & Expression
Additionally, allowing submissions in various formats, such as audio or video, as opposed to just written material, may allow students with communication difficulties to articulate their thesis statement easily. This may also help students with external stressors who are pressed for time to express their thoughts quickly, especially when writing can be a more extensive process.
Overall, implementing the Universal Design for Learning principles within the course and lesson is essential for all students, including those with disabilities.
Resources
Milton, G. (2021). [Women using a laptop] [Photograph]. Pexels. https://www.pexels.com/
Benton, D. (2020, February 6). UDL Guide Version 3. Universal Design for Learning. Retrieved February 10, 2024, from https://web.mohawkcollege.ca/centre-teaching-learning/apps/UDL/courseassessment/story_content/external_files/UDL%20Guide-Ver3.pdf
[DGDC - Deeply Graphic Designcast]. (2022, October 25). Building the Perfect Creative Brief [Video]. Spotify. https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/deeplygraphic/episodes/DESIGNCAST--Building-the-Perfect-Creative-Brief--DGDC-e1pojhb
Allcott, L. (2021, October 11). Reading on-screen vs reading in print: What is the difference for learning? National Library of New Zealand. Retrieved February 10, 2024, from https://natlib.govt.nz/blog/posts/reading-on-screen-vs-reading-in-print-whats-the-difference-for-learning
Simms, R. (2023, January 11). Dream Client Workbook. Broadbent Studio. Retrieved February 10, 2024, from https://mailchi.mp/2b09363628dc/dream-client-workbook
Glisch D., Lampkin C., Simms R. (2024). GMD 310 - Design Thesis Workshop [Syllabus]. School of Communications, Media, Arts and Design, Centennial College
OpenAI. (2024). ChatGPT (3.5) [Large language model]. https://chat.openai.com - Use for Brainstorming Ideas
Grammarly. (2024). Grammarly (Feb 11 version) [Large language model]. https://app.grammarly.com - Use it for grammar/spelling and polishing writing.
